| | American Idol - Official site. Includes information, screenshots, downloads, news and reviews. |
| | Elited (PlayStation 2) - Review, by Caroline Roberts: "American Idol is a fun game and is actually hard to put down." |
| | GameFAQs (PlayStation 2) - Includes information, links, reviews and a message board. |
| | GameSpot - Review (PlayStation 2) - Review, by Ryan Davis: "Though the rhythm game format seems like a natural fit for the American Idol property, its execution betrays the concept, and the end results just don't do the show justice." [Score: 5.1 out of 10] |
| | GameSpy.com - Review (PC) - Review, by the staff: "An uninspired mix of karaoke, board game, rhythmic challenges, and music video creation." [Score: 25 out of 100] |
| | Gaming Nexus (GameBoy Advance) - Review, by Cyril Lachel: "I know it's tempting for companies to attempt to bring a game to every possible game system, but sometimes you really don’t need a portable version." [Score: 3 out of 10] |
| | GamingWorld X (PlayStation 2) - Review, by Nick Pappas: "American Idol is one of those rare games that make you wonder how it is even authorized to be sold for a profit." [Score: 1 out of 10] |